Skip to content

🌱 CNCF mission generation 2026-03-09#326

Closed
github-actions[bot] wants to merge 1 commit intomasterfrom
cncf-gen-20260309-065325
Closed

🌱 CNCF mission generation 2026-03-09#326
github-actions[bot] wants to merge 1 commit intomasterfrom
cncf-gen-20260309-065325

Conversation

@github-actions
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

@github-actions github-actions Bot commented Mar 9, 2026

CNCF Mission Generation Report (All Batches)

Date: 2026-03-09T06:53:25Z
Batches: 14


Batch: generation-report-0.md

CNCF Mission Generation Report

Date: 2026-03-09T06:26:35.590Z
Total generated: 0
Skipped: 219
Errors: 0
Avg Quality Score: N/A/100
LLM synthesized: 0 | Regex fallback: 0

Projects Processed

Project Maturity Items Found Missions Generated Errors
argo graduated 20 0 0
argo-workflows graduated 16 0 0
argo-events graduated 2 0 0
argo-rollouts graduated 13 0 0
cert-manager graduated 20 0 0
cilium graduated 20 0 0
cloudevents graduated 3 0 0
containerd graduated 17 0 0
coredns graduated 6 0 0
cri-o graduated 13 0 0
crossplane graduated 18 0 0
cubefs graduated 0 0 0
dapr graduated 8 0 0
dragonfly graduated 0 0 0
envoy graduated 17 0 0
etcd graduated 16 0 0
falco graduated 11 0 0
falcosidekick graduated 4 0 0
fluentd graduated 3 0 0
fluent-bit graduated 11 0 0

Batch: generation-report-1.md

CNCF Mission Generation Report

Date: 2026-03-09T06:27:33.895Z
Total generated: 0
Skipped: 183
Errors: 0
Avg Quality Score: N/A/100
LLM synthesized: 0 | Regex fallback: 0

Projects Processed

Project Maturity Items Found Missions Generated Errors
flux graduated 1 0 0
flagger graduated 5 0 0
harbor graduated 9 0 0
helm graduated 20 0 0
in-toto graduated 3 0 0
istio graduated 13 0 0
jaeger graduated 8 0 0
keda graduated 15 0 0
knative graduated 13 0 0
knative-eventing graduated 9 0 0
kubeedge graduated 5 0 0
kubernetes graduated 20 0 0
linkerd graduated 7 0 0
linkerd-viz graduated 7 0 0
open-policy-agent-opa- graduated 5 0 0
prometheus graduated 11 0 0
alertmanager graduated 10 0 0
node-exporter graduated 5 0 0
pushgateway graduated 4 0 0
rook graduated 10 0 0

Batch: generation-report-10.md

CNCF Mission Generation Report

Date: 2026-03-09T06:44:48.061Z
Total generated: 0
Skipped: 22
Errors: 0
Avg Quality Score: N/A/100
LLM synthesized: 0 | Regex fallback: 0

Projects Processed

Project Maturity Items Found Missions Generated Errors
radius sandbox 2 0 0
ratify sandbox 0 0 0
runme-notebooks sandbox 0 0 0
schemahero sandbox 0 0 0
score sandbox 0 0 0
security-compliance sandbox 1 0 0
sermant sandbox 0 0 0
serverless-devs sandbox 0 0 0
serverless-workflow sandbox 1 0 0
shipwright sandbox 2 0 0
slimfaas sandbox 0 0 0
slimtoolkit sandbox 1 0 0
sops sandbox 7 0 0
spiderpool sandbox 0 0 0
spin sandbox 3 0 0
spinkube sandbox 0 0 0
stacker sandbox 2 0 0
submariner sandbox 3 0 0
telepresence sandbox 0 0 0
tinkerbell sandbox 0 0 0

Batch: generation-report-11.md

CNCF Mission Generation Report

Date: 2026-03-09T06:47:01.248Z
Total generated: 9
Skipped: 59
Errors: 0
Avg Quality Score: 63.8/100
LLM synthesized: 0 | Regex fallback: 9

Projects Processed

Project Maturity Items Found Missions Generated Errors
tokenetes sandbox 0 0 0
tremor sandbox 1 0 0
trickster sandbox 0 0 0
urunc sandbox 1 0 0
vineyard sandbox 0 0 0
virtual-kubelet sandbox 4 0 0
visual-studio-code-kubernetes-tools sandbox 0 0 0
wasmedge-runtime sandbox 1 0 0
werf sandbox 0 0 0
xregistry sandbox 0 0 0
kagenti community 2 1 0
llm-d community 0 0 0
vllm community 20 4 0
ollama community 20 2 0
localai community 2 0 0
kubeai community 0 0 0
litellm community 3 0 0
kuberay community 3 2 0
kubeflow community 5 0 0
open-webui community 4 0 0

Generated Missions

Mission Difficulty Quality Source
kagenti: ✨ Add MLflow integration for LLM trace observability advanced 62/100 link
vllm: [VLM] Qwen2.5-VL advanced 65/100 link
vllm: [Kernel] FlashMLA integration intermediate 61/100 link
vllm: [Model] Add Gemma 2 intermediate 65/100 link
vllm: [Model][VLM] Add Qwen2.5-Omni model support (thinker only) intermediate 65/100 link
ollama: added tools when stream=true beginner 66/100 link
ollama: Add metrics endpoint and request metrics intermediate 61/100 link
kuberay: [history server][storage] Add Azure Blob Storage support beginner 60/100 link
kuberay: feat: update RayCluster .status.reason field with pod creation error intermediate 69/100 link

Batch: generation-report-12.md

CNCF Mission Generation Report

Date: 2026-03-09T06:53:15.157Z
Total generated: 20
Skipped: 112
Errors: 0
Avg Quality Score: 62.6/100
LLM synthesized: 0 | Regex fallback: 20

Projects Processed

Project Maturity Items Found Missions Generated Errors
dify community 2 0 0
langflow community 1 1 0
flowise community 1 0 0
clickhouse community 20 3 0
milvus community 6 1 0
qdrant community 0 0 0
weaviate community 1 0 0
dragonfly community 0 0 0
valkey community 10 5 0
surrealdb community 10 1 0
redpanda community 2 0 0
nats community 1 0 0
kong community 9 0 0
apisix community 7 0 0
traefik community 20 4 0
caddy community 8 1 0
gitea community 20 4 0
woodpecker-ci community 13 0 0
drone community 0 0 0
signoz community 0 0 0

Generated Missions

Mission Difficulty Quality Source
langflow: feat: allow support for a root path beginner 61/100 link
clickhouse: Inverted Indices Implementation advanced 65/100 link
clickhouse: Add new table engine UniqueMergeTree intermediate 62/100 link
clickhouse: Support WebAssembly UDFs intermediate 60/100 link
milvus: Implement integer bitwise "and", "or" and "xor" operator. advanced 62/100 link
valkey: New hash table intermediate 62/100 link
valkey: Slot migration improvement expert 61/100 link
valkey: Trigger manual failover on SIGTERM / shutdown to cluster primary intermediate 61/100 link
valkey: Database-level access control expert 65/100 link
valkey: Fix incorrect lag reported in XINFO GROUPS intermediate 64/100 link
surrealdb: Refactor transaction, caching, and key-value store interfaces intermediate 61/100 link
traefik: Auto-negotiate Docker API Version advanced 67/100 link
traefik: Updates Docker Client API version 1.24 -> 1.44 intermediate 62/100 link
traefik: Allow discovering non-running Docker containers intermediate 62/100 link
traefik: Local private plugins. intermediate 61/100 link
caddy: caddytls: Encrypted ClientHello (ECH) beginner 65/100 link
gitea: Actions support workflow dispatch event intermediate 62/100 link
gitea: Add Package Registry advanced 63/100 link
gitea: Implement actions intermediate 60/100 link
gitea: Support Actions concurrency syntax advanced 66/100 link

Batch: generation-report-13.md

CNCF Mission Generation Report

Date: 2026-03-09T06:49:55.976Z
Total generated: 4
Skipped: 61
Errors: 0
Avg Quality Score: 62.8/100
LLM synthesized: 0 | Regex fallback: 4

Projects Processed

Project Maturity Items Found Missions Generated Errors
uptrace community 0 0 0
netdata community 5 2 0
keycloak community 17 0 0
vault community 6 2 0
consul community 4 0 0
tetragon community 3 0 0
minio community 3 0 0
seaweedfs community 0 0 0
n8n community 6 0 0
temporal community 0 0 0
backstage community 14 0 0
harbor community 7 0 0

Generated Missions

Mission Difficulty Quality Source
netdata: Docs: Add instructions to persist metrics and restart policy intermediate 66/100 link
netdata: self-cleaning obsolete cgroups and network interfaces from memory beginner 61/100 link
vault: Add Session tags and external id support for AWS Secrets beginner 63/100 link
vault: fix mongodb connection issue when using TLS client + username/password authentication beginner 61/100 link

Batch: generation-report-2.md

CNCF Mission Generation Report

Date: 2026-03-09T06:25:39.277Z
Total generated: 0
Skipped: 111
Errors: 0
Avg Quality Score: N/A/100
LLM synthesized: 0 | Regex fallback: 0

Projects Processed

Project Maturity Items Found Missions Generated Errors
spiffe graduated 0 0 0
spire graduated 1 0 0
the-update-framework-tuf- graduated 4 0 0
tikv graduated 12 0 0
vitess graduated 5 0 0
artifact-hub incubating 0 0 0
backstage incubating 14 0 0
buildpacks incubating 4 0 0
chaos-mesh incubating 11 0 0
cloud-custodian incubating 1 0 0
container-network-interface-cni- incubating 4 0 0
contour incubating 6 0 0
cortex incubating 2 0 0
emissary-ingress incubating 0 0 0
flatcar-container-linux incubating 0 0 0
fluid incubating 2 0 0
grpc incubating 10 0 0
karmada incubating 13 0 0
keycloak incubating 17 0 0
kserve incubating 5 0 0

Batch: generation-report-3.md

CNCF Mission Generation Report

Date: 2026-03-09T06:32:34.507Z
Total generated: 0
Skipped: 83
Errors: 0
Avg Quality Score: N/A/100
LLM synthesized: 0 | Regex fallback: 0

Projects Processed

Project Maturity Items Found Missions Generated Errors
kubeflow incubating 5 0 0
kubescape incubating 6 0 0
kubevela incubating 0 0 0
kubevirt incubating 16 0 0
kyverno incubating 6 0 0
lima incubating 9 0 0
litmus incubating 1 0 0
longhorn incubating 0 0 0
metal3-io incubating 7 0 0
nats incubating 1 0 0
notary-project incubating 1 0 0
opencost incubating 3 0 0
openfeature incubating 3 0 0
openfga incubating 2 0 0
openkruise incubating 1 0 0
opentelemetry incubating 3 0 0
opentelemetry-collector incubating 6 0 0
opentelemetry-operator incubating 4 0 0
openyurt incubating 3 0 0
operator-framework incubating 5 0 0

Batch: generation-report-4.md

CNCF Mission Generation Report

Date: 2026-03-09T06:32:17.531Z
Total generated: 0
Skipped: 40
Errors: 0
Avg Quality Score: N/A/100
LLM synthesized: 0 | Regex fallback: 0

Projects Processed

Project Maturity Items Found Missions Generated Errors
strimzi incubating 3 0 0
thanos incubating 7 0 0
volcano incubating 7 0 0
wasmcloud incubating 0 0 0
aeraki-mesh sandbox 0 0 0
akri sandbox 1 0 0
antrea sandbox 3 0 0
armada sandbox 1 0 0
athenz sandbox 0 0 0
atlantis sandbox 15 0 0
bank-vaults sandbox 1 0 0
bfe sandbox 0 0 0
bootc sandbox 0 0 0
bpfman sandbox 0 0 0
cadence-workflow sandbox 1 0 0
capsule sandbox 0 0 0
carina sandbox 0 0 0
cartography sandbox 1 0 0
carvel sandbox 0 0 0
cdk-for-kubernetes-cdk8s- sandbox 0 0 0

Batch: generation-report-5.md

CNCF Mission Generation Report

Date: 2026-03-09T06:33:41.833Z
Total generated: 0
Skipped: 29
Errors: 0
Avg Quality Score: N/A/100
LLM synthesized: 0 | Regex fallback: 0

Projects Processed

Project Maturity Items Found Missions Generated Errors
cedar sandbox 1 0 0
chaosblade sandbox 0 0 0
cloud-native-network sandbox 3 0 0
clusternet sandbox 1 0 0
clusterpedia sandbox 1 0 0
composefs sandbox 0 0 0
confidential-containers sandbox 1 0 0
connect-rpc sandbox 0 0 0
container2wasm sandbox 0 0 0
containerssh sandbox 0 0 0
continuous-optimization sandbox 1 0 0
copa sandbox 1 0 0
cozystack sandbox 0 0 0
dalec sandbox 0 0 0
devfile sandbox 2 0 0
devspace sandbox 1 0 0
dex sandbox 8 0 0
distribution sandbox 9 0 0
drasi sandbox 0 0 0
easegress sandbox 0 0 0

Batch: generation-report-6.md

CNCF Mission Generation Report

Date: 2026-03-09T06:38:39.950Z
Total generated: 0
Skipped: 42
Errors: 0
Avg Quality Score: N/A/100
LLM synthesized: 0 | Regex fallback: 0

Projects Processed

Project Maturity Items Found Missions Generated Errors
eraser sandbox 1 0 0
external-secrets sandbox 9 0 0
hami sandbox 2 0 0
headlamp sandbox 8 0 0
hexa sandbox 0 0 0
holmesgpt sandbox 2 0 0
hwameistor sandbox 0 0 0
hyperlight sandbox 0 0 0
inclavare-containers sandbox 0 0 0
inspektor-gadget sandbox 2 0 0
interlink sandbox 0 0 0
k0s sandbox 5 0 0
k3s sandbox 4 0 0
k8gb sandbox 1 0 0
k8sgpt sandbox 2 0 0
k8up sandbox 0 0 0
kagent sandbox 2 0 0
kairos sandbox 2 0 0
kaito sandbox 1 0 0
kanister sandbox 0 0 0

Batch: generation-report-7.md

CNCF Mission Generation Report

Date: 2026-03-09T06:38:50.068Z
Total generated: 0
Skipped: 21
Errors: 0
Avg Quality Score: N/A/100
LLM synthesized: 0 | Regex fallback: 0

Projects Processed

Project Maturity Items Found Missions Generated Errors
kcl sandbox 0 0 0
kcp sandbox 5 0 0
kepler sandbox 1 0 0
keylime sandbox 2 0 0
kgateway sandbox 1 0 0
kitops sandbox 0 0 0
kmesh sandbox 4 0 0
ko sandbox 1 0 0
konveyor sandbox 0 0 0
koordinator sandbox 0 0 0
kpt sandbox 0 0 0
kuadrant sandbox 1 0 0
kuasar sandbox 0 0 0
kube-burner sandbox 0 0 0
kube-ovn sandbox 1 0 0
kube-rs sandbox 2 0 0
kube-vip sandbox 0 0 0
kubean sandbox 0 0 0
kubearmor sandbox 2 0 0
kubeclipper sandbox 1 0 0

Batch: generation-report-8.md

CNCF Mission Generation Report

Date: 2026-03-09T06:40:10.488Z
Total generated: 0
Skipped: 41
Errors: 0
Avg Quality Score: N/A/100
LLM synthesized: 0 | Regex fallback: 0

Projects Processed

Project Maturity Items Found Missions Generated Errors
kubeelasti sandbox 0 0 0
kubefleet sandbox 0 0 0
kuberhealthy sandbox 1 0 0
kubeslice sandbox 0 0 0
kubestellar sandbox 5 0 0
kubewarden sandbox 0 0 0
kudo sandbox 0 0 0
kuma sandbox 1 0 0
kured sandbox 7 0 0
kusionstack sandbox 1 0 0
logging-operator-kube-logging- sandbox 0 0 0
loxilb sandbox 0 0 0
meshery sandbox 3 0 0
metallb sandbox 9 0 0
microcks sandbox 0 0 0
modelpack sandbox 0 0 0
monocle sandbox 0 0 0
network-service-mesh sandbox 0 0 0
oauth2-proxy sandbox 13 0 0
open-cluster-management sandbox 1 0 0

Generated from multiple knowledge sources across 14 batches.
Quality: avg score 0/100, 197 missions.

Signed-off-by: github-actions[bot] <41898282+github-actions[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
@kubestellar-prow
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

[APPROVALNOTIFIER] This PR is NOT APPROVED

This pull-request has been approved by:

The full list of commands accepted by this bot can be found here.

Details Needs approval from an approver in each of these files:

Approvers can indicate their approval by writing /approve in a comment
Approvers can cancel approval by writing /approve cancel in a comment

@kubestellar-prow kubestellar-prow Bot added do-not-merge/work-in-progress Indicates that a PR should not merge because it is a work in progress. dco-signoff: yes Indicates the PR's author has signed the DCO. size/XXL Denotes a PR that changes 1000+ lines, ignoring generated files. labels Mar 9, 2026
clubanderson added a commit that referenced this pull request Mar 10, 2026
Cherry-pick the one passing mission from the 2026-03-09 CNCF
generation run (PR #326). The remaining 32 missions have systemic
quality issues (wrong types, garbled steps, bogus prerequisites)
that need pipeline fixes before inclusion.

Signed-off-by: Andrew Anderson <andy@clubanderson.com>
@clubanderson
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Mission Quality Review β€” All 32 Remaining Missions: DROP

I reviewed each of the 33 auto-generated CNCF missions individually against their source PRs. The 1 passing mission (kuberay-639) was already cherry-picked to PR #330. All 32 remaining missions fail quality review and should be dropped.

Systemic Issues Found

Every mission has the same failures from the regex-based generation pipeline:

Issue Description Affected
Wrong type All 32 are marked troubleshoot β€” but they're feature PRs 32/32
Wrong prerequisites All require "Kubernetes cluster with kubectl" β€” many projects aren't K8s (Caddy, ClickHouse, Gitea, vLLM, Valkey, SurrealDB) 32/32
Garbled "Apply" step Contains Codecov coverage tables, git diffs, developer discussion, truncated PR prose 32/32
Generic filler steps "Understand the problem" β†’ "Verify the fix" boilerplate with no actionable content 32/32
CI bot spam as content Resolutions contain bot messages, PR format warnings, stale issue notifications ~10/32

Examples of Garbage Content

  • gitea-16510: "Apply configuration" step is a full Codecov coverage table with file-by-file percentages
  • milvus-24623: Resolution is literally a CI bot message about "Invalid PR Title Format Detected"
  • clickhouse-88747: "Apply configuration" step contains raw git diff output from CMakeLists.txt
  • caddy-6862: Prerequisites say "Kubernetes cluster with caddy installed" β€” Caddy has zero K8s relation
  • vllm-5908: "Apply configuration" step runs wget to download flashinfer binaries

Root Causes in Pipeline

  1. detectMissionType() defaults to 'troubleshoot' for everything
  2. generateSteps() grabs the first code block from ANY source (including Codecov comments)
  3. Prerequisites are hardcoded to K8s for all projects
  4. extractResourceKinds() false-positives on words like "Role", "Job", "Node" in non-K8s contexts
  5. LLM synthesis was not running β€” all 33 used synthesizedBy: "regex" fallback
  6. Quality threshold of 60 is too low β€” all scored 60-69

Recommendation

Close this PR. The pipeline needs fixes before the next generation run. I'll submit those fixes in a separate PR.

@clubanderson
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Closing: all 32 remaining missions fail quality review (see detailed comment above). kuberay-639 was already cherry-picked to PR #330. Pipeline fixes will be submitted in a separate PR.

clubanderson added a commit that referenced this pull request Mar 10, 2026
Cherry-pick the one passing mission from the 2026-03-09 CNCF
generation run (PR #326). The remaining 32 missions have systemic
quality issues (wrong types, garbled steps, bogus prerequisites)
that need pipeline fixes before inclusion.

Signed-off-by: Andrew Anderson <andy@clubanderson.com>
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

dco-signoff: yes Indicates the PR's author has signed the DCO. do-not-merge/work-in-progress Indicates that a PR should not merge because it is a work in progress. size/XXL Denotes a PR that changes 1000+ lines, ignoring generated files.

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant